Influencing in Enterprise Architecture and Some Strategies for Success
by
John P. Zachman
© 2024 John P. Zachman, Zachman International, Inc.
Enterprise architects (EAs) are recognized by many organizations as critical resources in achieving enterprise outcomes. Despite their pivotal role, EAs often lack direct authority over resources and personnel, making it essential for them to develop strong influencing skills. As they continually gather the necessary information to ensure that the enterprise's architecture is living and current and provides the best decision support to management, there are key strategies that EAs can use to influence their business leaders and stakeholders effectively. These strategies drive an engineered and relevant enterprise architecture, leading to organizational success through quality decision-making.
1. Building Relationships and Trust
Importance:
Solid and trust-based relationships are foundational for influence. When stakeholders trust an EA, they are likelier to be open, cooperative, and supportive. When stakeholders can trust that their Enterprise Architecture improves their ability to manage and quantify their decisions, trust is built long-term with their enterprise architects.
Strategies:
- Engage Early and Often: Regular stakeholder interactions help establish rapport and demonstrate commitment to the Enterprise Engineering mission.
- Active Listening: Show genuine interest in stakeholder concerns and priorities while being able to map their concerns to the architecture in a way that will not disengage them.
- Transparency and Honesty: Be clear about objectives, processes, and potential impacts, even if the news isn't always positive.
Benefits:
- Trust is built to help stakeholders define or redefine their motivation models.
- Enhanced cooperation and willingness to share information.
- Increased likelihood of stakeholder’s quality decisions.
2. Demonstrating Value
Importance:
Stakeholders are more likely to support things that demonstrate value to the organization. This leads to further connections with the organization’s enterprise architecture from stakeholders and shows an increased value of enterprise management from the architecture (or models). When Enterprise Architects can demonstrate how the architecture improves quality decisions and overall management, stakeholders are often surprised that their EAs are not just the technical people in their organization.
Strategies:
- Quantify Benefits: Use metrics, case studies, use cases, and forecasting through models to illustrate the tangible benefits of the enterprise architecture and predict the future impact of decisions.
- Align with Business Goals: Show how the Enterprise Architecture supports the organization's broader strategic objectives and enterprise engineering efforts.
- Quick Wins: Identify and execute “slivers” of the architecture that deliver immediate benefits to build credibility without stovepiping into more problems.
Benefits:
- Stakeholders see the relevance and importance of EA and how defining their architecture helps them manage the organization more effectively.
- Greater buy-in and resource allocation.
3. Effective Communication
Importance:
Clear and compelling communication is crucial for articulating EA's vision, goals, and benefits. EAs often tend to “get into the weeds.” Stakeholders do not need the excruciating level of detail that EAs frequently live in. If EAs can live in the Business Management Perspective as they communicate, stakeholders are more likely to see the benefit of developing the architecture to support and quantify their decisions.
Strategies:
- Tailored Messaging: Adapt communication styles and content to suit different stakeholder groups (e.g., technical details for IT and high-level overviews for executives).
- Storytelling: EA is difficult to understand because it is conceptual and not tangible. Use stories and analogies to make complex concepts more relatable and understandable.
- Visual Aids: Leverage diagrams, charts, and models and forecast the impact of decisions to represent ideas and progress visually.
Benefits:
- Creates tangible benefits from intangible concepts.
- Enhanced understanding and engagement from stakeholders.
- It is easier to convey complex information and secure support.
4. Leveraging Organizational Dynamics
Importance:
Understanding and navigating an organization's power structures and dynamics can enhance influence. Organizational champions, particularly at the management level, dictate much of enterprise architecture's success and failure. Too many EAs understand the value of engineering the enterprise but are limited by what they can do based on their understanding of it at levels above them.
Strategies:
- Identify Key Influencers: Recognize individuals with informal power and can sway others. Finding your champions above you who see the value of making organizational decisions based on actual enterprise data is critical. Also, identifying managers who rely only on their experience without enterprise data is essential so you know who will NOT see the value of decision support from Enterprise Architecture.
- Build Alliances: Form strategic partnerships with influential stakeholders and departments. Many C-suite folks tend to pigeonhole EA as something that comes out of their IT shop and want to leave the management to the “managers.” Build the right alliances with influential people who understand that Enterprise Architecture will only help them make strategic decisions.
- Understand Politics: Be aware of organizational politics and use this knowledge to navigate challenges and gain support.
Benefits:
- Increased ability to influence decision-making processes.
- More effective at garnering broad-based support.
5. Facilitating Collaboration
Importance:
Collaboration fosters a sense of ownership and collective responsibility among stakeholders. Organizations that understand that their Enterprise Architecture is a critical component of strategic decision-making make quality decisions without guesswork and feel. Look to create planning sessions among your alliances.
Strategies:
- Workshops and Brainstorming Sessions: Engage stakeholders in collaborative problem-solving and idea generation. Employ use cases to forecast quality decisions.
- Cross-Functional Teams: Create teams with representatives from various departments to ensure diverse perspectives and buy-in. Stakeholders from the executive and business management perspectives can gain invaluable information about the quality of their decisions from their EAs.
- Shared Goals: Establish common objectives that align with the interests of multiple stakeholders. The enterprise architecture can show integration and alignment of objectives.
Benefits:
- More significant innovation and comprehensive solutions.
- Enhanced stakeholder commitment to EA.
6. Providing Education and Training
Importance:
Educating stakeholders about the principles and benefits of EA can demystify the process and garner support. Once alliances are formed and Enterprise Architecture is understood to be more than getting systems and code to run, education through achieving objectives with the architecture will ensure long-term support for EA.
Strategies:
- Training Sessions: Offer workshops and training sessions to build stakeholder understanding, skills, and decision-making. Forecasting the result of decisions through architecture helps stakeholders understand the indispensability of EA.
- Documentation and Resources: Provide clear, accessible documentation for stakeholders.
- Mentorship Programs: Pair experienced EAs with new stakeholders to provide guidance and support.
Benefits:
- Increased stakeholder competency and confidence in the organization’s Enterprise Architecture.
- Reduced resistance due to a better understanding of EA and its management benefits.
Conclusion
Given their lack of direct authority, enterprise architects must rely on their influencing skills to effectively gather the necessary details to keep the organization’s Enterprise Architecture current and useful. By building relationships and trust, demonstrating value, communicating effectively, leveraging organizational dynamics, facilitating collaboration, and providing education and training, EAs can significantly enhance their influence and drive Enterprise Architecture to be successful decision support to management. These strategies ensure that EAs can navigate the complex landscape of stakeholder engagement and achieve alignment of strategic and organizational goals, quality decision-making, quantifying of the future, and organizational management through Enterprise Architecture.